New Facebook Layout is a Challenge for Management

facebookUnless you have been on the run from the police for the past couple weeks, you are already well aware of the radical layout changes to the Facebook home page. Most people have had an opportunity to test drive the new features, formulating an opinion on whether or not the modifications are worthwhile. Regardless of your thoughts on the new layout, it is important to point out that drastic layout changes of this nature are a huge challenge for the company managing the web property. Contrary to popular belief, most changes are not done on whim!

At first glance it probably appears as if Facebook merely took a page out of Twitter’s playbook and redesigned the site to be more like the micro-blogging service. While there was most certainly inspiration from Twitter’s design, the Facebook changes go much deeper. To use the cliché, rather than judging the book by its cover, you need to use Facebook extensively to see the modifications are essentially a building block for the future of the site and health of the company.

The thing about changes to huge web sites is this: transformation is performed on a whim. Even the slightest modification can have huge, lasting implications on both user morale and site performance. One small coding mistake not properly tested before being deployed to the live site may have consequences. Changes, especially those of this magnitude, are not taken lightly.

I say that because I speak from experience – in my tenure on deviantART we made countless design modifications, mostly after thorough review and consideration of the impact to our users – the very users who we rely upon for the success of the site. While some changes did not undergo the rigorous machinations others incurred, the basic operating philosophy is to seriously consider how changes affect our population.

Drastic changes like the Facebook layout modifications incur many costs and take a huge toll on management, especially when the perception of the changes are highly negative. Meeting rooms are filled with discussions on the ins-and-outs of the proposed changes, anticipating the possible user opinions on the various decisions. Ill will on a web site, especially if a huge percentage of the users are upset and the perception gains traction, can spell death for a site and causes nightmares for management.

In the case of the recent Facebook layout changes, one of the problems is the lack of communication from Facebook management. I posit that had Facebook management properly communicated the new changes the company would not find themselves in the situation they are in today. Had the impact to the users and why users would find the changes useful been presented to the community, in a clearly understandable manner, they would be a whole lot easier to stomach.

The problem is, and usually boils down to, a lack of communication that ultimately allows certain untruths to fester. If Facebook management truly believes in this layout, they need to communicate their thoughts to the people.

Trust me when I say it’s amazing what a little conversation can do to the community. Engage in communication with the community and its constitution will see dramatic increases in positivity! There is truly a direct correlation to be made there.

View Comments on “New Facebook Layout is a Challenge for Management”

Comments

1 Pete Mar 25th, 2009, at 04:11

Being someone who also experienced the changes that have happened over at deviantART I can say that communication helped a lot. Certainly the big overhaul that happened in 2003/4 was it? That was huge but the communication helped make the switch easier. I've been somewhat absent from the site but it has changed again but for the better.

As for Facebook, I have no issue with the re-design, in fact I kinda like it though the fact it doesn't auto-update is a shame. The one thing I do dislike though is the constant invites to petition groups to change it back. Robert Scoble wrote about the fact that despite peoples dislike it won't be changed (http://tinyurl.com/d39zrw) and he's right. I mean the last change, people were in arms but nothing was reverted and it won't change now.

However I agree that the impact could have been lessened with a bit of communication and openness from the brass over at Facebook. If this trend continues the community will only feel that they are disconnected from the community and will breed more discontent which is bad for their business. Time will tell if Facebook learn and may in the future be more communicative.

2 Denise Mar 25th, 2009, at 07:15

Agreed. Muchly.

3 Pete Mar 25th, 2009, at 15:41

Looks like they're trying too (http://blog.facebook.com/blog.php?post=62368742130) though still getting flack in the comments.

4 Scott Jarkoff Mar 25th, 2009, at 16:16

Indeed, it does appear they are attempting to communicate with the
community to some extent. I am glad to see the management reach out to
their users like this but fear they have not done enough to quell the
rioting masses.

Facebook is a huge monster so they have a substantial amount of people
to deal with on this issue. I definitely do not envy their position.

5 Rich Chuckrey Mar 26th, 2009, at 09:47

A site like Facebook has too much momentum for a layout change to change their membership in any drastic way. Even if 100,000 users complained and ditched FB, that would only be .0007% of the site's membership.

Write a comment

(required)

(required, but not published)

(optional)

You may use only these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

blog comments powered by Disqus