Why I Don’t Buy An i

ipod-iphoneI don’t buy iAnythings. Most people are in disbelief at this principle and question how I can refrain from buying such stylish, trendy and ubiquitous gadgets while others simply surmise that I’m trying to be coolly rebellious and anti-establishment. Right. The real story behind my anti-iAnything life principle is simply because the iExperience doesn’t live up to my life expectations.

Essentially, I bought my first mp3 player in 2001, which turned out to be the great-granddaddy of the iTouch – the 1st generation iPod. I was ecstatic with it, from the sleek look to the awesome touch wheel and the sheer amazement from the uneducated masses as they stared and wondered what it was. Nevermind that 6 short months later, a friend bought the 2nd generation iPod with twice the memory space at two-thirds the price. Then just over a year into the relationship, it happened – the headphones port stopped working properly. This should’ve been a relatively easy fix, but the kind people with the slightly impatient tone at the Apple store told me that iPods weren’t meant to be taken apart and its parts weren’t meant to be replaceable. If the iPod were built by Germans, it’d last a lifetime. Unfortunately, it wasn’t. Instead, it was built to be cost effective, so the iPod was built to be a flashy, trendy gadget that would be obsolete in under 2 years, and becomes a trendy paper weight if anything malfunctions.

In essence, I’m the kind of person who would spend the time researching the product that best suits me and is willing to spend the money on it, and subsequently keeps the product until it falls apart, is lost or stolen. For some reason, most of my gadgets get lost or stolen. I wouldn’t, for example, buy a gadget whose obsolescence is almost guaranteed within the next year, like the iPhone. Historically, the iPhone has been superceded by a new version within 1 year of release. In fact, the iPhone 3G was superceded by the iPhone 3GS in under 11 months at the WWDC. Of course, it doesn’t help matters that the iPhone was released without MMS capabilities or being able to forward SMSes, which made me think that Apple were complete doofuses for releasing a phone without such basic functions. Now with the upcoming release of iPhone OS v3.0 (the beta of which can already be found on the notorious Pirate Bay), Apple is as usual going out of their way to offer slightly useless but incredibly trendy apps, such as voice memos, stock apps, shake to shuffle and stereo bluetooth.

As for the iPods, each generation has been released on average just 9 months after the previous generation. Gen4 saw 3 releases within a year, and anyone who bought the first of Gen4 upon release got the proverbial finger from Apple as they released the iPod Photo just 3 months later. Granted, most gadgets or phones suffer the same short life cycle, but when this is coupled with a distinct refusal to replace parts, it’s a complete deal breaker for me. Of course, after the recent WWDC, I’m sure many like me are wondering how long the current iTouch/iPhone/iEtc will last.

Disclaimer: This article was written as an expression of personal opinion regarding a gadget with reference to suitability to my personal life. All points of view are welcome, flaming is welcome if you can handle a woman scorned. For further information, please click here.

  • http://www.yorickpeterse.com YorickPeterse

    You'd better put on your flame suit :P
    Anyways, I agree with you. The only 'Apple' thing I ever brought home was Mac OS X leopard, hackintosh that is. Still, I'm actually preparing to install Mint, but that's a different story.

    I've seen a lot of friends showing off with their iPhone, thinking they're awesome now they've experienced Apple.

    “Apple is so awesome, YEAH !”

    Common things you'll hear. There was a day nobody knew about Apple, other than those who used it (I've been using it since I could poop), but these days youre considered an outcast if you aren't a Mac fanboy.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Michael-Smith/501474923 Michael Smith

    You've only been pooping for close to two years? You said that the only Apple thing that you brought home was Mac OS X Leopard and then say you've been using it (Apple?) since you could poop…

    You sounded a bit like a mac fanboy earlier today on Smashing Magazine ;-)

    Your words:

    So if I’m right we should switch back to Windows because of Notepad++ ? What a joke. Many people don’t use mac because of the software, but because it just works.

    So how about that Linux Mint story? lol

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Michael-Smith/501474923 Michael Smith

    Good article, Haslina. I caved in and got an iPhone – not just because it's the cool thing but quite honestly, it really does work well. But, it took until close to a year after the 3G came out for me to get it. Then the 3G S comes out making my 3G $100 cheaper. It's a gamble I guess…wondering when the next gen of whatever i you buy will show up. I don't plan on buying the 3G S since the 3G works great and offers everything that I require. Sorry to hear about our bad iPod experience.

  • http://www.techmiso.com Haslina Ali

    I'll follow up by saying that I caved in and bought the iPod again in 2006 (whichever gen that was). And honestly, it worked fine. Unfortunately, I'd also had the iRiver just before that which I lost, and the only reason I bought the iPod was because I thought it'd be easier to get tech support for in Malaysia than the iRiver.

    It worked fine. Let's say that. But it didn't work as well as I wanted it to, and the sound quality was about as great as the built-in stereo system on a Tata.

    Footnote: I lost that iPod too, and now have an Archos. It's big and bulky, but damn I love this thing.

  • rastapete

    I don't get why the prospect of a newer device coming out in the next 11 months affects the utility that I get from buying one now. If the one that I buy gives me what I need from it who cares if there's another, 'better' one out next week, never mind next year.

  • fetus_over_easy

    FOE has 4 ipods- 'n counting and an iphone in the works. dammit.

  • http://www.techmiso.com Haslina Ali

    Do they all still work?

  • http://www.techmiso.com Haslina Ali

    Normally, it doesn't, unless the new release makes development of new apps incompatible with your current phone (http://technologizer.com/2009/06/10/how-iphone-…). Also, the bone I have to pick with them is more the case that they don't make gadgets to last and can't replace parts.

  • http://techmiso.com/ Rich Chuckrey

    Pete: Great point. If it works, why upgrade. Unless your pockets are just cash deep. However and unfortunately, there comes a time when upgrading just makes sense. One example is hardware and software that comes up on end of life with no continuing support. Red pill or the blue pill?

  • Terry

    Certainly one of the dumbest things I have read in quite awhile.

    I had one of the early iPods as well and it was built like a tank. The current iPods are extremely well made too. I guess you are one of those people who think if something is out of warranty they should repair it for free. It would also be a logical assumption that you don't buy any electronic device or pretty much anything else made today since very few things are designed have individual parts replaced or fixed.

  • fetus_over_easy

    yes. my first gen nano got a little weak in the knees so i bought an aftermarket case cracker/battery kit and together with some solder and snot, switched it out. in ipod years shes a fossil but still works fine as do my others.

  • http://www.techmiso.com Haslina Ali

    Actually, I think that it should be possible for people to replace parts like the headphone jack instead of having the company tell me that there's absolutely no way to fix it. I'd be willing to pay for them to fix it, if they only would, because then I'd get the benefit of continuing to use a device that I enjoyed.

    It's probably more logical to assume that I read many reviews on an electronic device before buying it, especially those relating to defects in the device, and weighing out the pros and cos, instead of just buying a device because everyone has it and it looks good.

  • http://www.pntaylor.net Pete

    I have 3 iPods at the moment and all still going strong. My first iPod (3rd gen I think, still had the play and that as seperate buttons) worked flawlessly and I passed it on to a friend who used it up until he bought a iPod touch a year or so ago. I replaced that iPod with a 5th gen iPod which I still use. I also got a 2nd gen Nano for running and gym and actually got a touch as well with the thought of my wife using my old one. I've never had a fault (*touches wood*) nor have I had to send any back. The same can be said about my iBook which is still going strong (passed to the same friend who I gave my first iPod to) along with my Macbook, iMac and iPhone.

    Like any product or manufacturer different people have different outcomes and opinions. Some people get great experience from products and they last forever. Other people buy the same thing and have nothing but trouble. My wife at one point had a Dell laptop but the poor thing had the worst track record for reliability. Couple with that was awful customer service and I vowed never to buy Dell for personal use. On the flipside I know people who have Dell's that have lasted forever and have been abused like you wouldn't know and still working without fault.

    In the end it's a personal thing and I can fault you for basing your thoughts off your experience.

  • http://www.yorickpeterse.com YorickPeterse

    My dad used to have a Mac, which I've been using since about 2000. So yes, Leopard is the only Apple thing I ever brought home.

    And about that on Smashing magazine, I just found the article was dumb. Switching back to a certain OS because of an text editor or Rocketdock is a joke.

  • Tom

    This is cool, finally someone who shares my view. This iphone/pod fad is has gone way out of hand. Having tried them, i can say that they r pretty n do cool things but useful things is a different matter.

    U should put a list of the gadgets u own, it will probably help me/like mined (enlighten) soul have an idea of whats good.
    :)